Wednesday, February 1, 2012

1201.6496 (Giovanni Amelino-Camelia)

Third road to the OPERA: a tunnel after all?    [PDF]

Giovanni Amelino-Camelia
The debate on OPERA focused on two extremes: either "OPERA is wrong" or our
formulation of the laws of physics needs a major overhaul. I here argue that
some effort should be directed toward manifestations of laws that are already
known, but whose implications are poorly understood in OPERA-type contexts. My
preferred example of this sort is that the OPERA result might be the first
observation of a previously unnoticed effect, belonging to a family of effects
which includes those responsible for the well-known peculiar properties of the
"tunneling time". Tentative support for this specific hypothesis comes from the
presence of evanescence and "postselection", and the observation that the
fraction of neutrinos absorbed in rock on the way from CERN to LNGS is of a few
parts in $10^5$, i.e. comparable to the fraction of the overall travel time by
which OPERA neutrinos are found to reach LNGS earlier than expected. This leads
me to stress that the OPERA result is still consistent with subluminality of a
suitably "postselection-corrected" velocity. Adopting the popular (but here
disfavored) interpretation of the OPERA result as a "signal velocity" one could
obtain superluminal values of the postselection-corrected velocity in some
technologically feasible OPERA-like setups, a prediction which I propose to
test. I also propose a semi-heuristic formula for the "rock dwell time" and
find that it gives a result in rough agreement with the OPERA travel-time
measurements. This suggests that effects similar to the ones found for OPERA's
muon neutrinos should also be found, but with tangibly different magnitude, for
muon anti-neutrinos under similar experimental conditions. And I argue that,
whether or not they end up being relevant for the OPERA anomaly, the effects
here considered should be significant in the Planck-scale realm.
View original: http://arxiv.org/abs/1201.6496

No comments:

Post a Comment